+91 22 62 43 43 43   

  • Call Me
  • Open Account
    • Open an Account
    • Fill Online Application
  • Margin Calc
  • IPO
  • Trading Login
    • ProStocks STAR
    • ProStocks Star Colo
    • ProStocks Star Web (Beta)
  • Backoffice Lite
ProStocks.comProStocks.comProStocks.com
  • Login
    • ProStocks STAR
    • Backoffice Lite
    • Backoffice Advance with Silver Light
  • Home
  • NRI
    • NRI Trading
    • Non-PIS NRO Trading
    • NRI Brokerage Calculator
    • NRI FAQs
  • API
    • ProStocks Star API
    • API Documentation
    • API SDK
  • Pricing
    • Pricing Plans
    • Brokerage Calculator
    • Margin Calculators
    • Trading Account Charges
    • Demat Account Charges
    • Stamp Duty Charges
  • Why Us
    • Why ProStocks?
    • Compare Brokers
    • Refer & Earn
    • Become a Partner
  • Trading
    • Trading Platforms
    • Collateral Pro
    • Fund Transfer
    • Trading Holidays
    • Minor Account
    • HUF Demat Account
    • FoxTrader
    • CDSL eVoting
  • Support
    • Contact Us
    • FAQs
    • Downloads
    • User Guide
    • Advance IVR
    • Blog
    • Press & Media

Return To ProStocks

  1. ProStocks
  2. Support
  3. FAQs
  4. NRI FAQs
NRI FAQs
23 January 2025
Hits: 1776

Why are Portfolio Management Services (PMS) better than Mutual Funds for NRIs based in the US and Canada?

Feature

Portfolio Management Services (PMS)

Mutual Funds

No PFIC Compliance Issues PMS investments involve direct ownership of stocks or assets, avoiding Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC) rules and simplifying tax reporting. Classified as PFICs under U.S. tax law, leading to higher tax rates (up to 37%) and complex reporting.
Personalized Portfolios Offers customized portfolios tailored to individual financial goals, risk tolerance, and preferences, including ethical or sectoral considerations. Follows a predefined strategy with pooled investments, limiting customization.
Greater Transparency Provides full visibility as investors hold stocks in their own name, with real-time portfolio performance and transaction history. Limited real-time disclosure of portfolio holdings.
Flexibility and Control Allows direct ownership and management of securities, offering flexibility to exclude specific stocks or industries. Standardized approach with minimal scope for customization.
Higher Investment Threshold Requires a higher minimum investment (e.g., ₹50 lakhs in India), ensuring tailored services for high-net-worth individuals. Designed for retail investors with lower investment thresholds and less personalized service.
Avoidance of Regulatory Barriers Operates on an individual basis, avoiding regulatory hurdles such as FATCA and Canadian securities regulations. Many AMCs restrict mutual fund investments for NRIs in the US and Canada due to compliance challenges.
Professional Management Managed by professional portfolio managers, with direct communication and personalized updates for clients. Managed by professionals but lacks direct client interaction or personalized updates.

When to Choose PMS over Mutual Funds


Scenario

Recommendation

Higher Investment Capital PMS is ideal for NRIs with significant investable surplus seeking a personalized and tax-efficient solution.
Customization Needs Choose PMS if a portfolio tailored to specific goals, industries, or ethical concerns is required.
Regulatory Convenience Opt for PMS to avoid PFIC compliance and FATCA complications, ensuring simpler tax compliance and higher post-tax returns.

Conclusion

PMS provides higher post-tax returns, simpler compliance, and greater personalization, making it a superior choice for NRIs in the U.S. and Canada compared to mutual funds.

Comments

Sort by Oldest First
Sort by Latest First
Subscribe:
Email
  • No comments found

Stickies

Lovies

Login to post a comment

Register · Forgot password

Post comment as a guest

    0

    Popular FAQS

    • What is KRA, KYC and IPV?
    • What is DP ID and beneficiary ID in Depository?
    • Who can open account with ProStocks?

    Categories

    • Account Opening
    • Trading
    • Demat
    • Fund Transfer
    • NRI FAQs
    • Back Office
    • Margin
    • Pricing

    Request Call Back



    Please check the reCAPTCHA box.


    • About Us
    • Fund Transfer
    • Fund Transfer FAQs
    • Downloads
    • Sitemap
    • Testimonials
    • Trading Holidays

    Need Help?

    Mumbai Office:
    B-50, Pravasi Estate, Goregaon (East), Mumbai - 400063

    Call us on +91 22 62 43 43 43 / +91 22 46 60 77 77

    Email: [email protected]

    Sunlight Broking LLP
    Registered Office:
    327, Govindam Tower, Old RTO Road, 3rd Floor, Gandhi Nagar, Bhilwara, Rajasthan, India 311001

    Registration Numbers:
    SEBI Regn. No.: INZ000048660 INDP2802016 | BSE Member code: 6635 | NSE Member code: 90084 | CDSL DP ID: 12083200 | AMFI Registration No (ARN): 119535


    Attention Investors

    Prevent unauthorized transactions in your demat account. Update your mobile number with your depository participant. Receive alerts on your registered mobile number for debit and other important transactions in your demat account directly from CDSL on the same day.
    Prevent unauthorized transactions in your trading account. Update your mobile numbers/email address with your stock brokers. Receive information of your transactions directly from the Exchange on your mobile/email at the end of the day. This is issued in the interest of investors.
    Client Registration Documents in Vernacular Languages can be download from here.
    Facility of Clearing Corporation for verification of Client Collaterals , please register on this link
    Investment in stock market are subject to market risk.
    No need to issue cheques by investors while subscribing to IPO. Just write the bank account number and sign in the application form to authorise your bank to make payment in case of allotment. No worries for refund as the money remains in investor's account.
    KRA-KYC is one time exercise while dealing in securities markets - once KRA-KYC is done through a SEBI registered intermediary (broker, DP, Mutual Fund, etc...), you need not undergo the same process again when you approach another intermediary. As a business we don't give stock tips, and have not authorized anyone to trade on behalf of others. If you find anyone claiming to be part of Sunlight Broking LLP and offering such services, please send us an email to [email protected]

    Investor Grievance: NSE | BSE | SCORE | SMARTODR | CDSL | [email protected]

    Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Management Policy and Procedure | Investor Charter | Risk Disclosures on Derivatives | KMP Details | Procedure for Filling of Complaint | CKYC | Voluntary Freezing | NATIONAL FINANCIAL LITERACY QUIZ (NFLQ)

    • NSE
    • |
    • BSE
    • |
    • RBI
    • |
    • AMFI
    • |
    • FM
    • |
    • CDSL
    • |
    • SEBI
    © , ProStocks

    ProStocks, A Sunlight Broking LLP Venture

    Please wait while we are processing your request.

    Loading...
    • Login
      • ProStocks STAR
      • ProStocks Star Web (Beta)
      • Backoffice Lite
      • Backoffice Advance with Silver Light
    • Home
    • NRI
      • NRI Trading
      • Non-PIS NRO Trading
      • NRI Brokerage Calculator
      • NRI FAQs
    • API
      • ProStocks Star API
      • API Documentation
      • API SDK
    • Pricing
      • Pricing Plans
      • Brokerage Calculator
      • Margin Calculators
      • Trading Account Charges
      • Demat Account Charges
      • Stamp Duty Charges
    • Why Us
      • Why ProStocks?
      • Compare Brokers
      • Refer & Earn
      • Become a Partner
    • Trading
      • Trading Platforms
      • Collateral Pro
      • Fund Transfer
      • Trading Holidays
      • Minor Account
      • HUF Demat Account
      • FoxTrader
      • CDSL eVoting
    • Support
      • Contact Us
      • FAQs
      • Downloads
      • User Guide
      • Advance IVR
      • Blog
      • Press & Media

    Request Callback for New Account

    Please check the reCAPTCHA box.

    Call Me Now

    For NRI callback, please submit request from NRI Trading