Edelweiss Vs Nirmal Bang - Broker Comparison

Compare ProStocks with popular brokers

Compare with Full-Service Broker
Compare with Discount Broker

Account Opening & AMC Charges

Compare account opening charges and annual maintenance charges (AMC)

	Standard Plan	Prepaid Plan - 6 Months	Prepaid Plan - 3 Months	Basic Plan
	Edelweiss Broking Ltd			Nirmal Bang Securities Pvt Ltd
Trading Account Opening Fee	₹750	₹750	₹750	₹0
Trading Account AMC	₹0	₹0	₹0	₹0
Demat Account Opening Fee	₹0	₹0	₹0	₹0
Demat Account AMC *	₹500	₹500	₹500	₹200

Brokerage Charges

Compare the commission charged by the brokers for the trades executed

	Standard Plan	Prepaid Plan - 6 Months	Prepaid Plan - 3 Months	Basic Plan
	Edelweiss Broking Ltd			Nirmal Bang Securities Pvt Ltd
Monthly Fee	NA	₹1250 for 6 months	₹1.11 Lakh for 3 months	NA
Equity Delivery	0.50%	0.45%	0.10%	0.20%
Equity Intraday	0.05%	0.05%	0.01%	0.02%
Equity Future	0.05%	0.05%	0.01%	0.02%
Equity Options	2.50% or ₹100 per lot	-	-	₹35 per lot
Currency Futures	0.03%	-	-	0.02%
Currency Options	₹15 per lot	-	-	₹20 per lot
Commodity	-	-	-	0.01%

Transaction Charges (Per Crore)

Compare Transaction Charges (Exchange Turnover Charges + Clearing Charges or PCM Fee)

	Standard Plan	Prepaid Plan - 6 Months	Prepaid Plan - 3 Months	Basic Plan
	Edelweiss Broking Ltd			Nirmal Bang Securities Pvt Ltd
Equity Delivery	NSE ₹325 \| BSE ₹275	NSE ₹325 \| BSE ₹275	NSE ₹325 \| BSE ₹275	₹390
Equity Intraday	NSE ₹325 \| BSE ₹275	NSE ₹325 \| BSE ₹275	NSE ₹325 \| BSE ₹275	₹390
Equity Future *	NSE ₹190 \| BSE ₹190	NSE ₹190 \| BSE ₹190	NSE ₹190 \| BSE ₹190	₹240
Equity Options *	NSE ₹5000 \| BSE ₹5000	NSE ₹5000 \| BSE ₹5000	NSE ₹5000 \| BSE ₹5000	₹5700
Currency Futures *	NSE ₹115 \| BSE ₹115	NSE ₹115 \| BSE ₹115	NSE ₹115 \| BSE ₹115	₹240
Currency Options	NSE ₹4000 \| BSE ₹4000	NSE ₹4000 \| BSE ₹4000	NSE ₹4000 \| BSE ₹4000	₹5700

Other Charges

Compare miscellaneous charges, minimum fees and add-on service rates.

	Standard Plan	Prepaid Plan - 6 Months	Prepaid Plan - 3 Months	Basic Plan
	Edelweiss Broking Ltd			Nirmal Bang Securities Pvt Ltd
Minimum Brokerage	3 paisa per share in delivery, 1 paisa per share on Intraday and Futures	3 paisa per share in delivery, 1 paisa per share on Intraday and Futures	3 paisa per share in delivery, 1 paisa per share on Intraday and Futures	-
Call & Trade	Rs 0	Rs 0	Rs 0	-
DP Charges (on sell side)	₹11 + ₹5.5 (CDSL) per scrip	₹11 + ₹5.5 (CDSL) per scrip	₹11 + ₹5.5 (CDSL) per scrip	0.03% (₹15 minimum per transaction)
Other Miscellaneous Charges	-	-	-	-

Demat Account Charges

Find charges for the best Demat Account for small investors

	Standard Plan	Prepaid Plan - 6 Months	Prepaid Plan - 3 Months	Basic Plan
	Edelweiss Broking Ltd			Nirmal Bang Securities Pvt Ltd
Depository Service Provider	CDSL	CDSL	CDSL	CDSL
Account Opening Fee	Nil	Nil	Nil	Nil
Advance Deposite	Lifetime AMC: ₹1500 one time (Star Scheme)	Lifetime AMC: ₹1500 one time (Star Scheme)	Lifetime AMC: ₹1500 one time (Star Scheme)	Life Time free AMC scheme Individual Account: ₹1000 One time Corporate Account: ₹2500 One time + ₹500 CDSL AMC (Per Year)
AMC	Star Scheme: Nil Regular Scheme (With POA or Non POA): ₹500 per year (Free for 1st year). Additional ₹500 will be charged annually for Corporate accounts.	Star Scheme: Nil Regular Scheme (With POA or Non POA): ₹500 per year (Free for 1st year). Additional ₹500 will be charged annually for Corporate accounts.	Star Scheme: Nil Regular Scheme (With POA or Non POA): ₹500 per year (Free for 1st year). Additional ₹500 will be charged annually for Corporate accounts.	Individual (Regular Demat Account): ₹200 Corporate (Regular Demat Account): ₹500 + ₹500 CDSL AMC Life Time free AMC scheme: Nil
Dematerialisation Charges	₹2 Per Certificate + ₹30 for Postage	₹2 Per Certificate + ₹30 for Postage	₹2 Per Certificate + ₹30 for Postage	₹40 Per Demat Request + ₹40 for additional 50 certificates
Rematerialisation Charges	₹10 per 100 securities or part thereof (Subject to min ₹10 per request) + ₹30 for Postage	₹10 per 100 securities or part thereof (Subject to min ₹10 per request) + ₹30 for Postage	₹10 per 100 securities or part thereof (Subject to min ₹10 per request) + ₹30 for Postage	₹15 per certificate or 0.04% of the value of the securities requested for remat whichever is higher
Transaction Charges (Credit)	-	-	-	-
Transaction Charges (debit)	Star Scheme Market Sell Within Edelweiss: ₹20 per transaction Off Market Transaction: ₹20 per transaction Regular Scheme (With POA) Market Sell Within Edelweiss: ₹20 per transaction Off Market Transaction: ₹20 per transaction Regular Scheme (Non POA) Market Sell Within Edelweiss: ₹25 per transaction Off Market Transaction: ₹20 per transaction	Star Scheme Market Sell Within Edelweiss: ₹20 per transaction Off Market Transaction: ₹20 per transaction Regular Scheme (With POA) Market Sell Within Edelweiss: ₹20 per transaction Off Market Transaction: ₹20 per transaction Regular Scheme (Non POA) Market Sell Within Edelweiss: ₹25 per transaction Off Market Transaction: ₹20 per transaction	Star Scheme Market Sell Within Edelweiss: ₹20 per transaction Off Market Transaction: ₹20 per transaction Regular Scheme (With POA) Market Sell Within Edelweiss: ₹20 per transaction Off Market Transaction: ₹20 per transaction Regular Scheme (Non POA) Market Sell Within Edelweiss: ₹25 per transaction Off Market Transaction: ₹20 per transaction	₹15 or 0.03% whichever is higher
Pledge Creation Charges	₹50 per transaction	₹50 per transaction	₹50 per transaction	₹100 or 0.02% whichever is higher
Pledge Creation Confirmation Charges	Nil	Nil	Nil	Nil
Pledge Invocation Charges	₹25 per transaction	₹25 per transaction	₹25 per transaction	₹100 or 0.02% whichever is higher
Failed Instruction Charges	Nil	Nil	Nil	Nil
Other Charges	Account Closing: Nil	Account Closing: Nil	Account Closing: Nil	-

Features

Compare key features offered the brokers.

	Standard Plan	Prepaid Plan - 6 Months	Prepaid Plan - 3 Months	Basic Plan
	Edelweiss Broking Ltd			Nirmal Bang Securities Pvt Ltd
Trading Platform	Mobile Trader Xtreme Trader Trader's Lounge	Mobile Trader Xtreme Trader Trader's Lounge	Mobile Trader Xtreme Trader Trader's Lounge	ODIN

ProStocks Vs

Compare Top Share Brokers

FAQs

Do I need to maintain any minimum balance in my ProStocks Trading Account?

No, there is no minimum balance / margin requirement while opening trading account with ProStocks. You only need to pay Rs 1000 as refundable deposit for demat account. Later on, you can transfer funds as per your trading requirements.

How much stamp duty I have to pay as a Maharashtra or a Rajasthan client?

We are charging .01% or Max Rs 50 per day as stamp duty except clients with Maharashtra and Rajasthan address. Maharashtra and Rajasthan clients pay .01% for Delivery and .002% for Intraday, Equity F&O and Currency Derivatives.

Stamp Duty regulation has changed from 1st July 2020

Read more for RECENT STAMP DUTY RELATED CHANGES

Request Call Back